Medici On 57th - A Delightful Blend of Bakery, Pizza, and Breakfast & Brunch

We just came in for a small bite and were honestly really impressed. The beef chili soup might be the best I’ve had in years. It was rich, flavorful, and hit the spot. The calamari was crispy and delicious, and the chili cheese fries were loaded and super satisfying. We also had the chips and guac which were fresh and solid. Service was great and everyone working there was super friendly. Chill spot and definitely somewhere I’d come back to.

It's all in what you order. Calamari me please. Pizza, for sure. Burgers, pass. Service is cool but when it got even semi-busy, we were forgotten about and ready to leave. BUT, they were pleasant. So I felt like maybe they were short-staffed or something, but I wasn't certain. Observing it seemed like they weren't. IDK. When the calamari came and tasted so good I was really eager for the burgers. They were just so/so. There's some great burgers in Hyde Park & in Chicago, so it's not my go to for that. But I had to try. The sauce for the calamari made me believe I needed to come back for the pizza, which they're known for. Yes and Amen. Come for the pizza and the appis. The brews were good & even though the waiter didn't know that part of the menu well he brought me the nicest guy who did & made good recommendations. Now I've heard their shakes are excellent, they're still on my to do list here. It's great for families or occasions where you don't mind noise.

Great Bloody Mary to start, loved the pesto chicken pasta and the loaded Garbage Pizza—both were excellent! Warm atmosphere and super friendly staff made the experience even better.

Food was excellent.. great portions , seasoned well with great taste. Prices are moderate and somewhat of a value when compared to portion and quality. Did witness a waitress picking some food of a plate that was about to be delivered and ate from it.. HOWEVER I told my server who told manager and they immediately took action, with a complimentary appetizer, dessert and an apology from the waitress who did it.. again our server, he was great and I didn't feel the need to punish him , so we did tip him based on the full amount , before discounts. Again , good food !!

Went to the self service desk and ate outside. The high-crust Spinach Pizza was tasty, a bit too cheesy. Size medium weighed almost too heavy afterwards. Would go smaller and for thin-crust next time. Price/Value very good. Thumbs Up!

I love this place so much! The food is always fresh and oh so delicious . Service is top-notch, and this place has a great ambiance. The baked goat cheese appetizer is my go-to. The Mediterranean pizza superb and the Ensalada kimba salad is perfection.

Medici on 57th is one of those neighborhood classics in Chicago’s Hyde Park that feels familiar from the first bite — a relaxed, eclectic spot where you can pop in for everything from comfort food classics to laid-back pizza and sandwiches. It’s been around for decades and has become a staple for locals, students from the University of Chicago, and anyone craving good, unpretentious food with a friendly vibe. The menu really runs the gamut: they do pan and thin pizzas, juicy burgers, hearty deli sandwiches, big salads, and a few classic American comfort dishes like chicken fingers or lasagna. The portions are generous and the prices are fair — perfect for a casual lunch or a low-key dinner without breaking the bank. I’d say the vibe here is classic Hyde Park cool — plenty of wood, casual seating, and yes, you can even scribble on the walls or tables with a Sharpie if you’re feeling playful (it’s kind of a tradition). It makes the place feel lived-in and welcoming, kind of like a favorite college hangout that still draws families and longtime neighbors too. There’s also a bakery next door where you can pick up fresh bread, croissants, pastries, and espresso in the morning, which adds a nice bonus if you’re stopping by earlier in the day. Not everything here is going to be fine-dining level — some dishes can be a bit average — but that’s kind of part of the charm. It’s approachable, fun, and consistently a good place to catch up with friends over simple, solid food. I’d definitely stop by for pizza, a sandwich, or even just one of their big milkshakes if you’re in the neighborhood.

Really cool place with some great vibes. Our first time trying deep dish pizza. its not easy to pick up